8 min read

Updated On Jun 2025
DessertFood HabitsHealth Benefits
Updated On Jun 2025

Ice Cream vs. Frozen Dessert: What’s Healthier and Why It Matters

Table of content

ice cream benefits

Written By

×
Author Profile
Sonali Khatu

Sonali Khatu, an IT engineer turned writer, captivates hearts with her enchanting words.

View Profile

Reviewed By

×
Varleen Kaur

Varleen Kaur is a Qualified Dietitian. In Fitelo, she is currently serving as a Subject Matter Expert, in the Department of Performance and Marketing.

View Profile

Table of content

Curious about the ice cream benefits? Eating ice cream activates the brain’s reward system by increasing dopamine, a neurotransmitter linked to pleasure and mood improvement. 

Additionally, the creamy texture and sweetness provide sensory comfort, making ice cream more than just a tasty treat; it can positively influence your emotional well-being.

In fact, a study by the Institute of Psychiatry in London found that eating ice cream immediately activates the orbitofrontal cortex, the part of the brain associated with happiness. Yes, that smile after a spoonful isn’t just in your head, it’s science!

Additionally, the carbohydrates in ice cream can trigger the release of serotonin, a neurotransmitter that boosts mood and reduces stress. And let’s not forget the calcium, essential for strong bones and teeth, which comes naturally with every creamy bite. 

In this blog, we’ll get into the surprising health benefits of ice cream, its flavorful history, and why this beloved dessert continues to be a favorite across the world. Ready for a scoop of insight? Let’s dig in.

CTA ImageCTA Image

Is Ice Cream Really Bad for You? Let’s Bust Some Myths

  • Not All Ice Creams Are Equal: A scoop from your local dairy isn’t the same as ultra-processed packaged tubs loaded with stabilizers, emulsifiers, and artificial flavors. Real ingredients matter.
  • Ice Cream in Moderation Can Be Fine: A small portion (like 2 scoops a week) of ice cream is good for health, as it is unlikely to affect a balanced diet. The problem arises with frequent or large portions, especially after meals already rich in carbs and fats.
  • Cold Doesn’t Mean Cold Symptoms: Many Indians avoid ice cream in winter, fearing colds. But there’s no scientific link between cold food and catching a cold. Viruses cause colds, not temperature. Moreover, better understand the symptoms of the common cold.
  • Calcium and Mood Boost: Dairy-based ice cream contains calcium, which supports bone health, and sugar, which, though limited, can elevate serotonin levels, boosting your mood temporarily.
  • The Real Risk Is in Pairing: It’s not just the ice cream, it’s when it’s paired with waffles, brownies, or gulab jamun that it turns into a sugar bomb.

Sugar And Fat: The Real Culprits or Overrated Fears?

  • Sugar: While added sugar in large amounts is undeniably unhealthy, most traditional Indian sweets exceed the sugar levels found in a small scoop of ice cream. So, demonizing ice cream alone is shortsighted.
  • Fat: Ice cream contains saturated fat, but not all saturated fat is harmful. Whole dairy fats or healthy fats are neutral or even slightly beneficial in some recent studies.
  • Portion control matters: A 100ml serving of standard vanilla ice cream typically contains 10g of sugar and 7g of fat, not insignificant, but manageable.
  • Metabolic health matters more: A person with a balanced metabolism can process occasional sugar/fat intake without issues, unlike someone with insulin resistance.
  • Overconsumption is the issue: People often combine ice cream with desserts like brownies or syrups, which compounds the calorie load, not the ice cream’s fault alone.

Homemade vs. Packaged Ice Cream

Advantages of ice cream include that it is homemade, allows you to control ingredients and freshness, avoiding additives and excess sugars. Packaged ice cream offers convenience but often contains preservatives and artificial flavors that impact health.

Homemade Ice CreamPackaged Ice Cream
Ingredients Transparency: Uses milk, cream, fruits, and minimal sugar, you know exactly what’s going into it.Hidden Ingredients: Often contains emulsifiers, stabilizers, and artificial flavors not clearly labeled.
Customizable Health Profile: You can reduce sugar, use organic milk or nut-based alternatives, and skip additives.One-Size-Fits-All Nutrition: Fixed sugar-fat ratio; rarely caters to health-conscious consumers.
Freshness & No Preservatives: Typically consumed within days, avoiding synthetic preservatives.Long Shelf Life: Preserved with chemicals to survive storage and transport, often at the cost of nutritional quality.
Higher Nutrient Value: Can be enriched with nuts, real fruit, and less processed dairy.Low Nutritional Value: May contain milk solids instead of real milk; focus is on flavor, not health.
More Effort, Better Payoff: Takes time to prepare, but offers control over ingredients and freshness.Convenient but Compromised: Readily available but often nutritionally poor.

Ice Cream Calories According To Different Flavours

Here’s a clear breakdown of the estimated calorie content for popular ice cream flavors based on a 1/2 cup (65-80 grams) serving. This will help you understand how different flavors compare in terms of energy intake.

FlavorCalories (per 1/2 cup serving)
Vanilla140-160
Chocolate150-170
Strawberry120-140
Mint Chocolate Chip170-190
Cookies and Cream160-180
Rocky Road170-190
Butter Pecan160-180
Coffee130-150
Pistachio150-170
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough170-190
Neapolitan (Mixed)130-150
Sorbet (Fruit-Based)100-130

Please note that these calorie values are approximate and can vary based on the brand and specific recipe of the ice cream. Always check the nutritional information on the packaging for the most accurate details.

Top 7 Health Benefits Of Eating Ice Cream

Top 7 Health Benefits Of Eating Ice Cream

1. Source Of Energy

Ice cream is a quick and tasty way to recharge your body with energy. Packed with sugars and fats, it offers an immediate energy boost, which can be particularly helpful during an afternoon slump or after physical activity. 

The simple carbohydrates in ice cream are rapidly digested, providing glucose that fuels your brain and muscles. Unlike energy bars or processed snacks, ice cream gives this burst of energy with a delightful taste, making it easier to consume when you need it most.

2. Calcium Boost for Stronger Bones

Dairy-based ice cream contains a healthy dose of calcium, an essential mineral for maintaining bone density and strength. 

Calcium plays a vital role in preventing osteoporosis and promoting healthy skeletal development, especially in growing children and older adults. 

Regular consumption of calcium-fortified ice cream, especially versions made with real milk, can supplement your calcium intake, contributing positively to your bone health over time.

3. Improves Mood & Reduces Stress

Eating ice cream stimulates serotonin and dopamine release, neurotransmitters that elevate mood and create feelings of relaxation, helping to calm the nervous system.

The creamy texture and sweet taste provide sensory pleasure, activating brain areas linked to reward and soothing emotional tension.

Taking a moment to enjoy ice cream mindfully can act as a brief mental break, lowering cortisol levels associated with stress.

Ice cream often connects to nostalgic experiences, which can evoke feelings of safety and happiness, further reducing anxiety.

4. Aids In Digestion 

Ice cream can act as a natural remedy to calm the burning sensation after eating spicy Indian food. The cold temperature soothes the heat, while the dairy content helps neutralize capsaicin, the compound responsible for spiciness. 

Additionally, the fats in ice cream coat the stomach lining, offering relief from irritation. This makes ice cream a surprisingly effective digestive aid after fiery meals.

5. May Boost Immunity 

Certain ice cream varieties, like kulfi or those made with yogurt, contain probiotics, beneficial bacteria that support gut health. A healthy gut microbiome is crucial for a strong immune system. 

Dairy fats and probiotics help enhance the body’s defense mechanisms by balancing harmful and helpful microbes. 

Plus, the vitamins and minerals naturally found in dairy contribute to overall immune function, making some ice creams an immune-friendly treat.

6. Helps in Weight Gain for Underweight Individuals

For people struggling to gain weight, ice cream offers a calorie-dense option that combines fats, sugars, and proteins in an enjoyable form. 

Unlike many processed snacks with empty calories, ice cream also provides essential nutrients, making it a more wholesome choice to supplement meals. Consuming ice cream as part of a balanced diet can support healthy weight gain when needed.

7. Rich in Vitamins like A, D, and B12 

Ice cream gets its vitamin content directly from the milk and cream used in its base. When made from real cow’s milk, it naturally contains:

  1. Vitamin A:  Found in milk fat, it helps maintain healthy vision, skin, and a strong immune system.
  2. Vitamin D:  Either naturally present or added during milk fortification, it supports calcium absorption and bone health.
  3. Vitamin B12:  Present in milk from animal sources, it’s essential for producing red blood cells and keeping the nervous system healthy.

However, low-fat or non-dairy ice creams may lack these vitamins unless they’re added during processing.

Note: While ice cream can offer small amounts of these vitamins, it’s not a primary source — but when made from quality dairy, it can help support daily intake, especially for people who consume less milk or cheese.

Best Times To Eat Ice Cream 

Enjoying the benefit of ice cream at the right time can help reduce guilt. Eating it earlier in the day gives your body more time to burn off the calories, making it a smarter choice than late-night snacking. Timing plays a key role in balancing enjoyment and health.

Afternoon Treat vs. Night Binge: What’s Better?

Enjoying ice cream earlier in the day gives your body more time to use those extra calories for energy, rather than storing them as fat. Late-night scoops? They’re more likely to disrupt sleep and slow digestion. So, if you’re picking a time, go for an afternoon treat over a midnight binge.

Post-Workout Option for Gaining Muscle Mass

Just finished a workout and trying to gain muscle? A scoop of ice cream can actually help — it provides quick-digesting carbs and calories your body needs to refuel. Pair it with a protein source like a shake or eggs for better muscle recovery and growth.

What Is the Difference Between Ice Cream and Frozen Dessert?

CategoryReal Ice CreamFrozen Dessert
Made WithReal milk and creamPalm oil, hydrogenated fats, and milk solids
Nutritional ValueNaturally rich in calcium and proteinHigh in bad fats, carbs, and synthetic additives
Fat Content (per 100g)5.6 g10.56 g
Carbs (per 100g)12.8 g25.28 g
Top IngredientsMilk, cream, sugarWater, sugar, palm oil, artificial flavor, and color
TextureCreamy, smooth, naturalWaxy, artificial, less rich
Health ImpactDigestible, supports bone healthCan harm heart health, digestion, and cholesterol levels
Common AdditivesNatural vanilla, cocoa, and fruit pulpTartrazine, liquid glucose, synthetic flavors
Label TipLook for “milk” or “cream” as the first ingredientAvoid if “palm oil” or “hydrogenated fat” is listed early

Ingredient Alerts

  • Palm oil = High saturated fat → raises LDL cholesterol
  • Milk solids ≠ Fresh milk
  • Artificial flavors & colors = Zero nutritional value

Desi Twists: Indian Ice Creams That Are Healthier

India’s love for ice cream takes a nutritious turn with these healthier desi versions. Using natural ingredients and low-sugar alternatives, these ice creams are a treat for both taste and health.

  1. Kulfi Made with Jaggery Or Coconut Milk

Ingredients:

  • 2 cups full-fat milk or coconut milk
  • 1/3 cup jaggery (grated)
  • 1 tbsp chopped almonds and pistachios
  • 1/4 tsp cardamom powder

Steps:

  1. Heat the milk on a low flame until it reduces to half. Stir often to avoid burning.
  2. Add jaggery and stir well until it dissolves.
  3. Mix in cardamom powder and chopped nuts.
  4. Pour the mixture into kulfi moulds and freeze for 6–8 hours.
  5. Unmould and enjoy a naturally sweetened kulfi.

2. Fruit-Based Sorbets: Natural and Refreshing

Ingredients:

  • 2 ripe mangoes or 2 cups watermelon
  • 1 tbsp lemon juice
  • 1–2 tbsp honey (optional)
  • A pinch of black salt (optional for a desi twist)

Steps:

  1. Blend the fruit pulp with lemon juice and honey until smooth.
  2. Pour into a shallow container and freeze for an hour.
  3. Stir and mash with a fork to break ice crystals.
  4. Repeat this 2–3 times every hour for a smooth texture.
  5. Scoop and serve chilled.

3. Low-Sugar Cassata: An Indian Retro Comeback

Ingredients:

  • 1/2 cup vanilla Greek yogurt
  • 1/2 cup strawberry puree
  • 1/2 cup chopped dry fruits
  • 1/4 cup low-sugar sponge cake (cut into thin slices)

Steps:

  1. Line a loaf pan with plastic wrap.
  2. Layer sponge cake at the bottom.
  3. Add yogurt, then strawberry puree, and top with dry fruits.
  4. Freeze for 4–6 hours.
  5. Slice and serve like classic cassata, minus the guilt.

Are There Any Side Effects Of Ice Cream?

While ice cream can be a delicious and enjoyable treat, it’s important to enjoy it in moderation. Here are some potential side effects of overconsumption:

1. Can Lead to Cravings & Dependency

Regularly eating ice cream, especially those high in sugar and fat, can trigger addictive eating patterns. This may make it harder to control portions or stop once you start.

2. Risk of Weight Gain & Obesity

Ice cream is calorie-dense and easy to overeat. Excessive intake, especially without physical activity, can contribute to unwanted weight gain and obesity-related health problems.

3. Digestive Discomfort

High-fat or dairy-rich ice creams can be heavy on the stomach. This may lead to bloating, gas, or indigestion, especially in people with lactose intolerance or a sensitive gut.

4. Raises Bad Cholesterol (LDL)

Some ice creams, particularly those with high saturated fat content, can increase LDL (bad) cholesterol levels over time, raising the risk of heart disease and other chronic conditions.

Enjoy ice cream occasionally, choose dairy-based natural options with lower fat and sugar, and always watch your portion sizes.

Consider making Your Own Ice Cream.

Try making a healthier version of ice cream at home, it’s easier than you think and lets you control the ingredients. Don’t miss our must-try homemade recipe!

Blueberry ice cream – Sugar-free Recipe

Sugar-free, homemade Blueberry Ice cream, anyone? This ice cream recipe is worth adding to your favorites list. It is full of nutrition and will keep you healthy and fit.

Easy Homemade Banana Ice Cream Recipe

Create your own delicious and healthy treat with our easy homemade banana ice cream recipe. Just a few simple steps to creamy, guilt-free goodness. Enjoy the natural sweetness of bananas in every scoop!

Mango-Banana Nice Cream Recipe

Whisk up a tropical delight with our refreshing Mango-Banana Nice Cream recipe. Indulge in the luscious blend of mango and banana, guilt-free. Discover a naturally sweet and creamy treat that’s perfect for any time of the year!

Chocolate Ice Cream Oats – Healthy Dessert Recipe

Indulge in a guilt-free delight with our Chocolate Ice Cream Oats recipe. Satisfy your sweet cravings while enjoying the goodness of wholesome oats. Discover a healthier way to enjoy dessert without compromising on taste!

Coffee Ice Cream Recipe

Awaken your taste buds with our irresistible Coffee Ice Cream recipe. Delight in the perfect blend of rich coffee flavor and creamy goodness. Experience a homemade frozen treat that’s sure to please coffee and dessert enthusiasts alike!

A Quick Summary

Ice cream often gets a bad rap, but not all ice cream is created equal. Real, dairy-based ice cream can be part of a balanced diet if enjoyed in moderation. 

While over-processed packaged versions with artificial additives may raise health concerns, homemade or quality dairy ice creams offer benefits like calcium, energy, and even mood-boosting effects.

Why Is Ice Cream Considered Unhealthy?

The concerns come mainly from sugar and saturated fat, though dairy fats can be neutral or even beneficial. The bigger issue is overconsumption, especially when ice cream is paired with calorie-dense desserts like brownies or gulab jamun.

For people with insulin resistance, portion control is key. Also, cold foods like ice cream do not cause colds; that’s a myth.

Types of Ice Cream

Homemade ice cream uses real milk, cream, and natural ingredients with customizable sugar levels. Packaged ice creams often contain preservatives, artificial flavors, and stabilizers, making them less nutritious.

How Do We Recognize Healthy Ice Cream?

Look for options with:

  • Real dairy or fruit
  • No artificial additives
  • Moderate sugar levels

Benefits of Ice Cream

  • Quick Energy from glucose and fat
  • Bone Health via calcium
  • Mood Boosting by increasing serotonin
  • Digestive Soothing after spicy meals
  • Immunity Support with probiotics (in some types)
  • Weight Gain Support for underweight individuals
  • Rich in Vitamins A, D, B12

Best Times to Eat Ice Cream

Eating ice cream earlier in the day or post-workout can help minimize guilt and support muscle recovery. Avoiding night-time binges is better for metabolism and overall health.

How To Make Healthier Choices?

  • Opt for fruit-based sorbets
  • Try low-sugar kulfi with jaggery
  • Make homemade banana or blueberry ice cream

Moreover, here are some of the 10 reasons why ice cream is good for you, and you can enjoy them at any moment.

How To Know Which Of These Is A Type Of Frozen Dessert?

Is differentiating between ice cream and frozen dessert difficult for you? Let’s make it easy. Check out this video of Dietitian Mac Singh and get to know how to recognize a real ice cream.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Ice Cream Good For Health?

In moderation, ice cream provides calcium and energy. However, high sugar and fat content may affect heart and metabolic health if consumed excessively or without a balanced diet.

What Benefits Does Eating Ice Cream Have?

Ice cream offers calcium for strong bones, some B vitamins, and a quick energy boost. It also promotes temporary mood improvement due to its taste and pleasurable experience.

Is Ice Cream Good For Skin?

Ice cream is not particularly beneficial for skin. Its high sugar content can contribute to acne and inflammation, though dairy does provide small amounts of skin-supportive nutrients.

What’s The Best Time To Eat Ice Cream?

The best time to eat ice cream is after meals, especially lunch or dinner, as a dessert. This helps reduce sugar spikes and supports better digestion and portion control.

CTA ImageCTA Image

Contact Us Today

Get in touch with our expert team at Fitelo to kick-start your transformative journey! Let us guide you toward your weight loss goals and help you cultivate sustainable and healthy eating habits. So contact us today and take the first step towards a healthier, happier you with Fitelo!

Disclaimer

This blog was written to help you make healthy and better food choices. So, be aware and take care. The vital thing to consider is your health before starting a restrictive diet. Therefore, before starting, always seek advice from a doctor/dietitian if you have any concerns.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Get access to 1000+ healthy and tasty recipes, fitness tips and more. Subscribe to our newsletter

Get fit with the easiest weight loss journey planned by certified experts. Whatsapp Whatsapp Us Talk To An Expert